login
Updated 09/12/2026
0

Ta PVD Target Racetrack Erosion Reduces Target Utilization - Functional Modeling

Cause and Effect Chain #

In the Ta PVD process, the sputtering target develops a deep erosion groove in the narrow racetrack region. As a result, the target must be replaced while a significant amount of expensive tantalum remains unused. This reduces target utilization, shortens target life, and increases manufacturing costs.

The erosion is believed to result from the magnetron magnetic field, which concentrates the plasma and Ar⁺ ion bombardment in a limited area. The same mechanism that enables efficient Ta deposition therefore causes localized target erosion. Reducing the deposition rate provides only minor improvement while decreasing throughput. Cause and Effect Chain Analysis will identify the fundamental causes of nonuniform erosion and determine where the chain can be broken without compromising deposition performance.



We learned that the PVD equipment does not provide uniform erosion of the Ta sputtering target.

Sep 12 2026 8:56:40 am
Functional Modeling #

The Ta PVD system consists of a vacuum chamber, Ta sputtering target, magnetron assembly behind the target, power supply, gas delivery system, wafer support, shields, and vacuum pumps. The wafer is positioned opposite the target. Argon is used as the process gas; nitrogen may be added for reactive TaN deposition.

Electrical power creates an Ar plasma. Ar⁺ ions bombard the Ta target and eject Ta atoms, which travel through the chamber and form a thin barrier film on the wafer. The magnetron’s magnetic field confines electrons near the target, increasing plasma density and sputtering efficiency, but also concentrating target erosion within the racetrack region.


Let’s define the Product. The Product is what the system is designed to create. In our case, the Ta PVD system is designed to deposit a Ta/TaN thin film.

Therefore, the deposited Ta/TaN thin film is the Product.



Very large diagram. Click "View" to display.
Operational Effectiveness – OE

Effective

Ineffective

OE 0.48
Operational Perfectness - OP

Basic functions

Components

Supersystems

OP 0.07
Functional rank
Problematic rank
Ar+ ions
15
60
Ta sputtering target
10
Ta atoms
10
Magnetron
7
63
TaN
6
Periphery of the target
4
4
Nitrogen
4
RaceTrack area
4
4
Ar plasma
3
Field
3

Either compensate for magnetic-field non-uniformity with temperature, or compensate for magnetic-field non-uniformity with magnetic-field control or target-shape compensation.


Sep 12 2026 9:27:13 am
Component: Magnetron #
(by Functional Modeling)
Contradiction:
If
Magnetron remains unchanged
Then
Magnetron Creates Field
But
Magnetron Splits Ar+ ions
Improving parameter
Description of what is improving:
The field creation directs the Ar+ ions to the Ta sputtering target and releases Ta atoms
Selected improving parameter:
Temperature
Worsening parameter
Description of what is worsening:
The field is concentrated between the V and S poles and does not provide equal heating of the Ta target.
Selected worsening parameter:
Shape
Matching principles:
  • 14
    Spheroidality - Curvature
  • 19
    Periodic action
  • 22
    Blessing in disguise (Turn Lemons into Lemonade)
  • 32
    Color changes
  • Sep 12 2026 10:01:17 am
    Login to comment

    Similar projects

    The process is related to microelectronics - microchip manufacturing. The purpose of the process is to create a SiO2 layer on the surface of a Si wafer. Equipment: Vertical furnace to heat the wafers in the Q2 atmosphere and perform oxidation on the wafer surface. Process: The oxidation occurs on the front side and on the back side of the wafer Requirements: Create a SiO2 thin layer with a certain thickness and low sigma - low standard deviation of the thickness between the wafers and within the wafer Failure: Wafers from the lower zone have higher thickness and significantly higher within wafer sigma (standard deviation of the thickness within the wafer)

    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky
    Mike Agulyansky avatar
    Alex Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar

    Wet cleaning is widely used in microchip manufacturing. Single wafer equipment is working as follows. A wafer rotates, and chemistry is poured from a movable nozzle. Water rinsing is performed at the end of the process. Loading of a new batch of the chemistry resulted in excursion - a strongly increased amount of defects was observed on the wafer after the processing. The project is dedicated to the failure analysis and creation of innovative solutions.

    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky
    Mike Agulyansky avatar
    Max K avatar
    Alex Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar

    This project applies Functional Modeling to analyze the single-wafer wet etch process in semiconductor manufacturing. The model shows that wet etch defects are not caused only by chemistry, but also by interactions between the wafer, liquid flow, air, rotation, rinsing, drying, drain, and chamber environment. Key challenges include incomplete wetting, trapped air or bubbles, residue and particle redeposition, evaporation-driven watermarks, and contamination during rinse or drying. The project identifies improvement directions such as better wafer pre-wetting, controlled airflow, reduced evaporation, optimized rinse and drying conditions, and alternative chamber concepts such as face-down processing in a shallow liquid bath.

    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky
    Alex Agulyansky avatar