login
Updated 06/11/2026
11

Wafer breakage at flash heating

Cause and Effect Chain #

Wafer breakage within the flash heating system:

The flash heating with the upper lamp created the gradient of the temperature of the air. The fast-changing of temperature results in the wind (tornado) formation that leads to the movement of the wafer. The moving of the wafer may result in a mechanical hit followed by the wafer breakage.

May 29 2022 3:12:51 pm
5 Whys #
Causes Chain
Root Cause Analysis

Wafer breakage occurs at flash heating

Why?

Run additional wafers to compensate for the broken wafers

3

A mechanical hit occurs

Why?

Redesign the pedestal or add a ring having no "walls" - no parts that the wafer can hit

2

Wafer moves due to air pressure difference appearing due to flash heating

Why?

Fixate the wafer - no movements at all (vacuum chuck?)

0

The pedestal has a special configuration: the wafer moves and can get a mechanical hit

This is the fundamental reason for the problem (FRP).

Redesign the pedestal to exclude a mechanical hit

0
Jun 12 2022 1:04:05 pm
Functional Modeling #

How wafer breakage occurs while the flash heating process:

Operational Effectiveness – OE

Effective

Ineffective

OE 0.59
Operational Perfectness - OP

Basic functions

Components

Supersystems

OP 0.39
Functional rank
Problematic rank
Pedestal
8
Low lamp
6
Bumps
4
Centering pins
4
24
Upper light (flash)
4
Atmosphere (N2)
12
Air
8

The main conclusion is that we need to exclude either movement of the wafer or vertical solid parts that the wafer can hit

Jun 12 2022 1:18:45 pm
Component: Centering pins #
(by Functional Modeling)
Contradiction:
If
Centering pins remains unchanged
Then
Centering pins Hold Wafer
But
Centering pins Stops Wafer
Apr 17 2026 4:11:33 pm
Inventive principles #
Contradiction:
If
we exclude the wafer movement
Then
no breakage will occur due to a mechanical hit
But
The thermal stress could appear and affect the parameters of the product or even result in breakage due to thermal stress
Improving parameter
Description of what is improving:
No breakage will occur
Selected improving parameter:
Shape
Worsening parameter
Description of what is worsening:
thermal stress will occur
Selected worsening parameter:
Strength
Matching principles:
  • 10
    Preliminary action
  • 14
    Spheroidality - Curvature
  • 30
    Flexible shells and thin films
  • 40
    Composite materials
  • Jun 12 2022 1:32:07 pm
    Cause and Effect Chain #

    Wafers break due to flash heating

    Let's analyze the possibility of a mechanical hit during the flash heating process

    May 12 2026 9:25:37 am
    5 Whys #
    Causes Chain
    Root Cause Analysis

    Wafer got a mechanical hit during the flash heating process

    Why?

    Mechanical hit of the wafer with centring pins

    Why?

    Redesign centering pins with flexible, low-friction polymer coatings or spring-loaded tips that absorb minor impacts and allow self-centering without causing damage during wafer movement.

    The wafer should move during the flash heating process

    Why?

    Keep the wafer against movement

    Nitrogen gas moves and moves the wafer

    Why?

    Redesign the quartz pedestal with additional low-profile support ridges or pins positioned to provide lateral stability to the wafer, preventing displacement from gas flows while maintaining uniform light exposure.

    Rapid thermal expansion of chamber gases inducing convective currents

    Why?

    Process in a vacuum or at least in low pressure

    Different temperatures cause different pressures of nitrogen

    Why?

    Add the same flight on the bottom to get the same temperature

    Flash heating is needed for implant ions activation

    This is the fundamental reason for the problem (FRP).

    Integrate in-situ plasma-assisted activation during implantation to partially activate ions, reducing the reliance on subsequent high-temperature flash heating steps.

    May 12 2026 9:38:41 am
    Login to comment

    Similar projects

    Wet cleaning is widely used in microchip manufacturing. Single wafer equipment is working as follows. A wafer rotates, and chemistry is poured from a movable nozzle. Water rinsing is performed at the end of the process. Loading of a new batch of the chemistry resulted in excursion - a strongly increased amount of defects was observed on the wafer after the processing. The project is dedicated to the failure analysis and creation of innovative solutions.

    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky
    Mike Agulyansky avatar
    Max K avatar
    Alex Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar

    The process is related to microelectronics - microchip manufacturing. The purpose of the process is to create a SiO2 layer on the surface of a Si wafer. Equipment: Vertical furnace to heat the wafers in the Q2 atmosphere and perform oxidation on the wafer surface. Process: The oxidation occurs on the front side and on the back side of the wafer Requirements: Create a SiO2 thin layer with a certain thickness and low sigma - low standard deviation of the thickness between the wafers and within the wafer Failure: Wafers from the lower zone have higher thickness and significantly higher within wafer sigma (standard deviation of the thickness within the wafer)

    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky
    Mike Agulyansky avatar
    Alex Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar

    Copper electroplating is essential for forming advanced semiconductor interconnects, yet radial thickness non-uniformity remains a costly challenge. Thicker deposition at the wafer edge and thinner copper at the center force manufacturers to rely on overplating and CMP compensation, increasing material waste and process cost. Using the PRIZ Platform, this project reveals that the true amplification mechanism lies in operating within a kinetically controlled regime, where small voltage variations caused by seed-layer resistance produce large thickness deviations. By shifting the process closer to diffusion-controlled behavior and reducing sensitivity to voltage fluctuations, uniform deposition can be achieved intrinsically — enabling thinner seed layers, reduced overplating, lower CMP burden, and overall cost reduction.

    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky
    Alex Agulyansky avatar