login
•
Updated 09/27/2026
•
11
•
•

Wafer cleaning issues at the wet process

Cause and Effect Chain #

To analyze why the defects remain on the wafer while cleaning with chemistry.

The process is as follows:

  • a wafer is kept in the special chuck in 4 points
  • chemistry pores from the nozzle on the wafer
  • the wafer rotates allows removing the chemistry from the wafer together with the defects
  • parameters of the process - chemistry flow, temperature, process time, wafer rotation rate and so on can be adjusted

It seems like the process conditions are not optimal

Linear (5+ whys) analysis is needed to search for a root cause of insufficient defects removal with the chemistry and with water at rinsing

The most important point is that chemistry does not perform the process properly - improve the process is needed

Jan 14 2022 12:51:51 pm
5+ WHYS Analysis #
Causes Chain
Root Cause Analysis

Defects remain on the wafer surface after the wet cleaning process step

Why?

Try to eliminate the washing. Do we really need this?

0

Because the wet process does not remove the defects

Why?

To increase the density of the chemistry by temperature reduction.

4

Defects remain on the wafer till the very end of the process.

Why?

Ensure that the chemistry remains on the wafer as long as possible (reduce rotation of the wafer)

1

The chemistry is removed from the wafer before it removes the defects

Why?

Reduce evaporation rate of the chemistry, reduce rotation of the wafer

0

Because the chemistry contaminates the wafer due to impurities or other properties

This is the fundamental reason for the problem (FRP).

Replace the chemistry

0
Jan 14 2022 3:42:52 pm
Inventive principles #
Contradiction:
If
The wafer will be washed as much as needed.
Then
A big amount of chemistry or water will remain on the wafer during the cleaning process.
But
The process cost will be significantly increased.
Improving parameter
Description of what is improving:
Big amount of chemistry or water will be on the wafer
Selected improving parameter:
Volume of moving object
Worsening parameter
Description of what is worsening:
Unpredictably high cost of the process due to the usage of big amount of chemistry or water for rinsing
Selected worsening parameter:
Loss of energy
Matching principles:
  • 7
    Nesting dolls
  • 13
    The Other way around
  • 15
    Dynamism
  • 16
    Partial or excessive action
  • Jan 15 2022 10:13:14 am
    Effective Brainstorming #

    Defects remain on the wafer surface. The wet cleaning process suddenly becomes ineffective.

    Let's apply the Effective Brainstorming (EBS) tool to generate ideas and prioritize them.

    Implementation: Easy, Validation: Easy
    Increase the time of rinsing
    2
    Apr 10 2022 11:45:47 am
    Increase the temperature of rinsing water
    2
    Apr 10 2022 11:45:02 am
    Increase the time of cleaning
    1
    Apr 10 2022 11:45:29 am
    Reduce rotation rate
    1
    Apr 10 2022 11:46:04 am
    Implementation: Easy, Validation: Not Easy
    Adjust clean air pressure
    2
    Apr 10 2022 11:43:02 am
    Check and adjust the pressure
    1
    Apr 10 2022 11:42:44 am
    Replace filter
    0
    Apr 10 2022 11:43:54 am
    idea
    Sep 25 2026 10:57:49 am
    Implementation: Not Easy, Validation: Easy
    Check and adjust the flow
    Apr 10 2022 11:42:07 am
    Implementation: Not Easy, Validation: Not Easy
    Reduce the temperature of the chemistry
    4
    Apr 10 2022 11:44:33 am
    Replace pump
    3
    Apr 10 2022 11:44:16 am
    Add filter
    1
    Apr 10 2022 11:44:06 am
    Change spec limits
    1
    Apr 10 2022 11:47:32 am
    Replace the chemistry
    1
    Apr 10 2022 11:46:42 am
    Apr 10 2022 11:33:33 am
    Functional Modeling #

    The purpose of the wet etch process is to clean the wafer, dissolve and remove all soluble material, and remove insoluble material as small particles carried by the solution flow.

    Defects remain on the wafer surface after the wet cleaning process step.

    Single wafer wet cleaning system.

    The chemistry is poured on the rotated wafer to remove the stuff and not leave residue or particles. The wafer rotates, and the solution with the dissolved and movable particles is removed from the wafer by centrifugal forces.

    Pure air operates as an important component of the system (not a supesystem component). Pure air is filtered by an air filter, but it might also move air particles within the chamber, and can stimulate the evaporation of the solution from the wafer

    The sketch of the chamber is shown below:

    Very large diagram. Click "View" to display.
    Operational Effectiveness – OE

    Effective

    Ineffective

    OE 0.22
    Operational Perfectness - OP

    Basic functions

    Components

    Supersystems

    OP 0.02
    Functional rank
    Problematic rank
    Frontside Chemistry
    17
    17
    Wafer
    12
    Residue
    5
    5
    Stuff to remove
    5
    Backside chemistry
    5
    Chuck
    4
    Chemistry particles
    3
    Frontside nozzle
    3
    Pump
    3
    Chemistry Filter
    2

    The most problematic components are Air and Front side Chemistry:

    Do we really need an airflow? Maybe it would be better just filter without a fan. The exhaust will compensate for the pressure variations.


    Front side chemistry is also the most functional component. It means the improvement can be achieved by variation of the chemistry parameters

    All components of low functionality can be trimmed.

    The functionality of the Exhaust can be significantly improved by relocation within the chamber



    The general conclusion is to eliminate the air supply and exhaust system.

    Let air enter the chamber and convert exhaust to drain with very little under-pressure.

    This will stabilize the performance, reduce the evaporation rate of the chemistry, reduce the cost and simplify the system.

    May 7 2022 11:41:59 am
    Functional Modeling #

    Defects remain on the wafer surface after the wet cleaning process step.

    Single wafer wet cleaning system.

    The chemistry is pored on the rotated wafer to remove the stuff and not leave residue or particles.

    The sketch of the chamber is shown below:

    Operational Effectiveness – OE

    Effective

    Ineffective

    OE 0.39
    Operational Perfectness - OP

    Basic functions

    Components

    Supersystems

    OP 0.09
    Functional rank
    Problematic rank
    Chuck
    12
    Front side chemistry
    8
    20
    Pump
    4
    Residue
    4
    4
    Tank with chemistry
    4
    Back side chemistry
    4
    Air
    3
    77
    Air particles
    2
    2
    Heater
    2
    Chemistry filter
    2
    6

    The air flow is the most harmful component - prevent air flow to avoid drying and evaporation of the chemistry that results in the leaving of the residue on the wafer surface

    Jun 13 2022 8:40:11 am
    Functional Modeling using AI #

    The system is built for wet cleaning of silicon wafers. The wafer rotates and the solution is delivered through a nozzle to the center of the wafer. The solution purpose is to dissolve the defects and remove the defects both chemically and mechanically from the wafer. The problem is that the process is not very effective and some defects remain on the wafer.

    Pure air passes into the chamber and since the air can keep particles the filter is installed in the top of the chamber. Nevertheless, filter does not stop all the particles and the particles fall down to the wafer and additionally contaminate the wafer. The air, even pure air, also increases the evaporation of the solution, which reduces the time of the interaction of the solution with the defects and with the residue that remains on the wafer.

    Please avoid using supesystem here - all the parts of the system should be taken and treated as components of the system.

    Also we need to take into account that the chemistry wets the wafer, moves the particles and residue on the wafer

    Definition of defects: defects are particles that remain on the wafer.


    We suspect that the solution is flying away from the wafer too fast


    The scheme of the wet cleaning system is shown in the picture below:

    Operational Effectiveness – OE

    Effective

    Ineffective

    Operational Perfectness - OP

    Basic functions

    Components

    Supersystems

    Functional rank
    Problematic rank
    Component
    No impact
    Oct 25 2025 11:31:54 am
    Login to comment

    Similar projects

    The process is related to microelectronics - microchip manufacturing. The purpose of the process is to create a SiO2 layer on the surface of a Si wafer. Equipment: Vertical furnace to heat the wafers in the Q2 atmosphere and perform oxidation on the wafer surface. Process: The oxidation occurs on the front side and on the back side of the wafer Requirements: Create a SiO2 thin layer with a certain thickness and low sigma - low standard deviation of the thickness between the wafers and within the wafer Failure: Wafers from the lower zone have higher thickness and significantly higher within wafer sigma (standard deviation of the thickness within the wafer)

    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky
    Mike Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar
    Alex Agulyansky avatar

    This project investigates radial non-uniformity of CDO low-k dielectric deposited by PECVD and its possible impact on wafer performance. Final test data indicate that faster dies are mainly located closer to the wafer center, while slower dies are more often found near the wafer periphery. The corresponding RC-delay trend also increases toward the wafer edge. The focus of the project is the capacitance component of RC-delay. CDO is expected to provide a low dielectric constant between BEOL metal lines, but the deposited film may not have uniform properties across the wafer. Near the wafer edge, the process can be influenced by different gas flow, plasma behavior, residence time, temperature, and pumping conditions. This may lead to stronger oxidation and deeper precursor decomposition near the periphery, forming CDO that is more oxygen-rich, less carbon-rich, denser, and closer in behavior to SiO₂. As a result, the dielectric constant k may increase toward the wafer edge, causing higher interline capacitance, higher RC-delay, and lower die speed. The project uses Functional Modeling to understand how PECVD chamber components and process conditions affect CDO film properties. The goal is to identify the main functional and problematic interactions and propose directions for compensation, such as radial gas-flow tuning, multi-zone showerhead design, edge compensation flow, and local plasma or temperature control.

    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky

    This project investigates the nonuniform erosion of an expensive Ta sputtering target during Ta/TaN PVD. A deep racetrack groove forces target replacement while a significant amount of tantalum remains unused. Using PRIZ problem-solving tools, the project explores the system’s functions, identifies the root causes of localized erosion, and develops ways to improve target utilization without reducing deposition rate or production throughput.

    Anatoly Agulyansky avatar
    Anatoly Agulyansky
    Alex Agulyansky avatar